Read my blog at Huffington Post

I also blog at Huffington Post's new UK site; please click here to read my posts there.

Saturday, 24 January 2009

BBC DEC row: confusions and contradictions

I am a passionate supporter of the BBC and its editorial independence. I strongly resent any row in which shouty people try to force the BBC to change an editorial decision. The price we pay for the BBC's neutrality is that it sometimes makes decisions with which one disagrees - and nobody should seek to shout those decisions down, however unpalatable they may sometimes be. The BBC's decision not to show the DEC Appeal is the BBC's decision and the BBC's decision alone. It is ironic that the very people (including Government ministers!) who are now insisting that the BBC change its mind are accusing other people of having bullied the BBC! Pot, kettle, etc. I suggest that the DEC could produce a Gaza appeal which is in line with the BBC's editorial policy and rules on impartiality. The Red Cross, a constituent body of the DEC, is raising funds for Palestinian AND Israeli civilians affected by this conflict. For example, at time of writing, if you text LIFE to 81400, it will cost you £1.50, most of which will be split equally between a hospital in Gaza and a hospital in Israel. Israel too has had its wounded, and the emergency medical service Magen David Adom (which gets no govenment funding) has faced greatly increased costs as a result of Hamas' rocket attacks (and Magen David Adom has opened a field hospital for wounded Palestinians in Gaza, with an emergency room and four ambulances to take patients to Israeli hospitals). Surely DEC could produce an appeal, based on the Red Cross's work, that the BBC would consider impartial and so be able to broadcast? Of course, the immense suffering of Palestinian people in this latest Gaza conflict far outweighs that of Israelis (which has still been considerable). It is vital to get aid into Gaza and I applaud British charities' work there. If the BBC does decide to show the DEC Appeal after all, then I will not be opposed to that. What I oppose is bullying of the BBC by politicians and others who insist that the BBC MUST show this appeal - hands off the BBC! Especially you Government Ministers, Messrs Bradshaw and Alexander. A final thought: a recent poll ( if you scroll down to the questions about Gaza) of UK public opinion shows that 24% of people blame Hamas for the Gaza War, 18% blame Israel and 58% blame both sides equally or are not sure who to blame. That 58% do not go on demonstrations or shout angrily at the BBC. But they do pay their licence fee and expect the BBC to be an utterly impartial guide to the deeply complicated politics of Israel, Palestine and the wider Middle East.


  1. The BBC has a complaints procedure, you seem to be tarring those of us actually complaining about something they're doing through the proper channels with those that complain after the fact because of a tabloid fuss.

  2. Not that I have gotten involved in this row in any way, but don't you think that since we are actually forced on pain of court action to pay for the BBC we have an absolute right to shout them down if we want to. Or at least we would in a democracy.

  3. even if we do pay it is their duty, as we all pay and are all to be represented even though we cannot for it is not a governmental institution, to be unbiased and stay that way for they are mainly a medium of news and would lose their credibility otherwise. I respect their choice and cannot fathom other peoples disagreement at their well founded decision. That is probably why i am not in politics...cheers

  4. I agree that it is fine for a viewer to complain to the BBC; I sometimes do myself! But that is different from politicians using their power to try to force the BBC to reverse an unpopular editorial decision. Jock, I don't believe in pure democracy, I believe in liberal democracy and the rule of law. I want a BBC that exercises its judgment impartially and resists JS Mill's 'tyranny of the majority'.

  5. Hi Matthew,

    Thanks for your article, interesting read. Please could you post a link to the poll which you cite at the end?

    Thanks :)

  6. Hi Matt

    Good point - the poll is at: if you scroll down to the questions on Gaza.